Happy Thanksgivukkah!

It’s that time of year again, when we come together with our families to celebrate and enjoy the harvest. Here at the Dairy Godmother we make a bit of a fuss about Thanksgiving, and we think you should too!

Again this year we’re offering our famous Frozen Custard Pies, which have a gingery crust filled with Frozen Custard and make a lovely addition to any desert spread. We also offer special Pilgrim Cakes in addition to our popular Pumpkin Custard Sandwiches, fancy hand-dipped Truffles, and dainty homemade Marshmallows. It’s all on the flyers!

If you’d like to place an order for any of these wondrous things you can pop on down to the shop and fill out an order form, send an email, or call (leave a message!). Keep in mind that treats will be available for pick-up the week of Thanksgiving, starting Monday the 25th. We’re going to be open special for the event on Tuesday the 26th from 12-9, and on open from 10am until 10pm on Wednesday the 27th  Be sure to specify which day you’re going to pick up your goodies.   We Are NOT open on Thanksgving Day this year!

We also have Holiday Crackers! These fun party favors will really punch up your event. They open with a bang and contain confetti, a paper crown, a bad joke, and a small toy! We have made some special ones just for Thanksgiving and some more special ones just for Hanukkah! We have plenty here in the shop for you and yours!

We’ll be closed on Friday, November 29th for family time, but open at 11am on Small Business Saturday with the once-a-year Drumstick flavor!


  • Closed Tuesday's.