Give Thanks for Custard!

Hello everyone!

The leaves are falling all around, so come on down to The Dairy Godmother and enjoy our fancier fall flavors of Wisconsin-style Frozen Custard, homemade fruit Sorbets, or handy and exotic Ice Pops! Every day we have vanilla and chocolate custards, as well as a Flavor of the Day. You can print out a calendar of custard flavors from here.

Our bakery case is back in full swing now, so look out for are apple crisps, marshmallows, moonpies, snickerdoodles, ginger cookies, buttered pecans, and good ol’ chocolate chips to accompany your frozen tasties!

We’ve started taking orders for Thanksgiving treats!  Thanksgiving order forms are out in the shop for the first few weeks of November, and treats can be picked up the week of the 19th. We’ll be closed on Monday, open on Tuesday and Wednesday during normal shop hours that week, and from 9 am till noon on Thanksgiving (Thursday the 22nd.) We’re taking Friday off to recover from food comas.

In other news, the 37th Annual Turkey Trot is happening an hour earlier this year, starting at 9am. Dress warm and have fun, but don’t forget to pick up your Thanksgiving goodies!

Order this for Thanksgiving. Pick it up the day of ,if you wish…

Available Tuesday the 20nd, Wednesday the 21rd and

Thursday the 22th (open 9 am – noon)

First Come, First Served

Frozen Custards Quarts: $8.00

To compliment your own family pie. Pints :   $5.12

Mozambique (cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves)

Sweet potato with candied pecans


And, of course, vanilla

Sorbets Quarts: $8.00

For a palate cleansing intermezzo Pints:   $5.12

between courses, or a nice light dessert with cookies.

Cranberry with coriander and tangerine

Roasted pear with vanilla

Apple cider

Don’t forget something for the host/hostess…

Unusually delicious gift ideas…

Pumpkin Moon Pies

Truffles (Seasonal flavors)

Box of 6 assorted Marshmallows

Pumpkin Ginger Custard Sandwiches

Assorted Ice Pops (buy 9, get 1 free!)

Pumpkin Puppy Pops for your host dog

Gift packaging available for an additional $1.00

Open Thanksgiving Day from 9 a.m. – 12 noon !!!

Thanksgiving Treats

Available for Special Order

Pumpkin Custard Pies

Pumpkin frozen custard in a ginger cookie crust, decorated with maple leaf cookies

and whipped cream rosettes.   Also available in Sweet Potato-Pecan.            $16.25

Pilgrim Cakes

Vanilla frozen custard and cranberry sorbet between layers of spice cake, covered with whipped cream and decorated with whipped cream rosettes.

One size only:         $21.95

Pumpkin Ginger Custard Sandwiches

Pumpkin frozen custard and ginger cookie sandwiches.                                $3.39 ea.

Gelato or Sorbet Truffles

Seasonal flavors, hand-dipped in bittersweet chocolate.       Box of six: $10.95

Box of Assorted Marshmallows

Seasonal flavors, in a box with a bow.                                           Box of six: $4.39

  • Closed Tuesday's.